Ratings of Candidates in 2016 Elections

For the November 2017 contested judicial election in the Washington Court of Appeals, KCBA rates Judge Michael Spearman as "Exceptionally Well Qualified" and Attorney Nathan Choi as "Refused to Cooperate."  A press release about KCBA's ratings in this race is available here.

Judicial Candidate Forums

KCBA hosted candidate forums in September, in which all judicial candidates in contested elections were invited to participate. The events focused on issues of interest to the legal community, and were open to the public for in person attendance at the KCBA office or online simulcast via our website.

The original event flyer is available here.

2016 KCBA Judicial Candidate Evaluation Ratings

last updated 10/3/16

The King County Bar Association publishes ratings for any candidate who has filed election paperwork with the state Public Disclosure Commission or the King County Elections Department, provided we have issued a rating. KCBA is committed to releasing ratings in every contested judicial election that appears on the King County ballot, as well as for any candidate who requests a rating. Generally incumbent judges running unopposed do not seek ratings. Candidates with “rating pending” have not yet supplied all reference materials to KCBA – though materials were requested from all candidates on June 1. KCBA plans to issue ratings for all candidates, including those who do not provide materials, by September 30. King County ballots are mailed on October 19. Those who do not respond may receive a “not qualified” or “refused to cooperate” rating.

For additional information on KCBA’s work with judicial candidate and officer evaluations, visit www.kcba.org/judicial/ratings/ratings.aspx. To learn more about all judicial candidates, please visit www.votingforjudges.org.

CONTESTED RACES

Supreme Court Position 1
CANDIDATE KCBA RATING WEBSITE
David DeWolf Well Qualified www.dewolfforjustice.org
Mary Yu (incumbent) Exceptionally Well Qualified www.justicemaryyu.com
Supreme Court Position 5
CANDIDATE KCBA RATING WEBSITE
Barbara Madsen (incumbent) Exceptionally Well Qualified www.chiefjusticemadsen.org
Greg Zempel Well Qualified www.zempelforjustice.org
Supreme Court Position 6
CANDIDATE KCBA RATING WEBSITE
David A. Larson Well Qualified www.larsonforjustice.org
Charles K. Wiggins (incumbent) Exceptionally Well Qualified www.justicecharliewiggins.com
Superior Court Position 14
CANDIDATE KCBA RATING WEBSITE
Nicole Gaines-Phelps Qualified www.electnicolegainesphelps.com
David Greenspan Not Qualified www.greenspanforjudge.com
Superior Court Position 26
CANDIDATE KCBA RATING WEBSITE
David Keenan Well Qualified www.keenanforjudge.com
John H. O’Rourke Qualified www.johnorourkeforjudge.com
Superior Court Position 31
CANDIDATE KCBA RATING WEBSITE
Helen Halpert (incumbent) Exceptionally Well Qualified www.retainjudgehelenhalpert.com
Marc S. Stern Qualified www.sternforjudge.com
Superior Court Position 44
CANDIDATE KCBA RATING WEBSITE
Catherine Moore Qualified www.cathymooreforjudge.com
Eric Newman Exceptionally Well Qualified www.electnewmanjudge.com
Superior Court Position 52
CANDIDATE KCBA RATING WEBSITE
Anthony Gipe Well Qualified www.gipeforjudge.com
Kristin V. Richardson Exceptionally Well Qualified www.richardsonforjudge.com
Superior Court Position 53
CANDIDATE KCBA RATING WEBSITE
Thomas Cline Not Qualified www.clineforjudge.com/
Mariane Spearman (incumbent) Exceptionally Well Qualified www.retainjudgespearman.com
District Court Position 3
CANDIDATE KCBA RATING WEBSITE
Laurel Gibson (incumbent) Well Qualified www.retainjudgegibson.com/
Brian J. Todd Well Qualified www.facebook.com/BrianJTodd4DistrictCourt

UNCONTESTED RACES

Superior Court Position 7
CANDIDATE KCBA RATING WEBSITE
Janet Helson (incumbent) Exceptionally Well Qualified N/A
Superior Court Position 8
CANDIDATE KCBA RATING WEBSITE
John Ruhl (incumbent) Exceptionally Well Qualified N/A
Superior Court Position 21
CANDIDATE KCBA RATING WEBSITE
Veronica Alicea-Galvan (incumbent) Exceptionally Well Qualified N/A
Superior Court Position 28
CANDIDATE KCBA RATING WEBSITE
Johanna Bender (incumbent) Exceptionally Well Qualified N/A
Superior Court Position 29
CANDIDATE KCBA RATING WEBSITE
Sean O'Donnell (incumbent) Exceptionally Well Qualified N/A  
Superior Court Position 33
CANDIDATE KCBA RATING WEBSITE
Steven G. Rosen Well Qualified www.electjudgerosen.com
Superior Court Position 41
CANDIDATE KCBA RATING WEBSITE
Matthew Williams Well Qualified N/A
Superior Court Position 43
CANDIDATE KCBA RATING WEBSITE
John McHale Exceptionally Well Qualified www.mchaleforjudge.com
Superior Court Position 46
CANDIDATE KCBA RATING WEBSITE
Judy Ramseyer (incumbent) Exceptionally Well Qualified N/A
District Court Position 1
CANDIDATE KCBA RATING WEBSITE
Lisa Paglisotti (incumbent) Exceptionally Well Qualified N/A
District Court Position 4
CANDIDATE KCBA RATING WEBSITE
Gregg Hirakawa (incumbent) Qualified N/A
Working to improve the administration of justice is an important part of the King County Bar Association’s mission.

KCBA has evaluated and rated judicial performance since 1948 through surveys of current judicial officers, ratings for those seeking appointment or election to the bench, and monitoring of fair campaign practices and hosting of candidate forums.

Judicial Candidate Evaluation Ratings Process
Fair Campaign Practices Guidelines
Judicial Officer Surveys
Current Judicial Openings
Candidate Forum Archives